(Tom Shapiro/Sara Evans/Tony Martin)

Ooh
Why Should I Care If You Found Somebody New
And You Look Like You're In Love
And Why Should I Care If She Looks A Lot Like Me
And She's All You've Ever Dreamed Of
I Didn't Care Enough To Keep You Around
So Tell Me Why Should I Care Now

I Was The One Who Let You Go
I Never Told You That I Love You
I Couldn't Promise Anything
The Way You Needed Me To
Oh, My Heart Was Never Really There
So Why Should I Care
Why Should I Care?
I Just Do

So Why Should I Care If
I Ain't Nothing In Your Eyes
What You Felt For Me Is Gone
Oh, And Why Would I Feel That Way
Now That It's Too Late
To Change What I Did Wrong
Oh, I Didn't Care Enough To Keep You Around
So Baby, Tell Me, Why Should I Care Now

I Was The One Who Let You Go
I Never Told You That I Love You
I Couldn't Promise Anything
The Way You Needed Me To
Oh, My Heart Was Never Really There
So Why Should I Care
Why Should I Care?
Well, I Just Do

Oh, My Heart Was Never Really There
So Why Should I Care
Why Should I Care
I Just Do
Yeah, I Just Do
Baby, I Just Do